At The Strategy Group, preliminary interviews are a big part of what we do. Between our own hiring and the search work we run for clients, we conduct more first-round video interviews than most organizations will in a year. Recently, we’ve heard from a number of employers who rely on virtual interviews as a screening step but feel their process could be sharper. We hear you, and we’ve been there. Here are a few of the do’s and don’ts we keep coming back to.
Preliminary video interviews have become the default first step in most hiring processes. They’re efficient, easy to schedule, and easy to underestimate, by interviewers as much as by candidates. A screen that’s run casually produces casual results: strong candidates slip through the cracks, and weaker ones advance on charm alone. Done well, it’s one of the most valuable 30 minutes in your entire hiring process.
THE DO’S
- Do know what the screen is for. Before the first call, decide what this round needs to answer. Is it baseline qualifications, motivation, communication, or salary alignment? A screen that tries to do everything ends up doing nothing well. A clear purpose keeps the conversation focused and makes the yes/no decision easier.
- Do ask every candidate the same core questions. Consistency is what makes a screen fair and useful. If each conversation goes in a different direction, you end up comparing impressions instead of candidates. Leave room for follow-ups but anchor every call to the same foundation.
- Do take notes in real time. Memory is unreliable, especially after back-to-back calls. Capture specifics while they’re fresh, meaning what the candidate actually said, not just how you felt about it.
- Do set the candidate up to succeed. Send the link, the expected length, and who they’ll be speaking with well in advance. A candidate who isn’t scrambling for logistics shows you who they really are.
- Do hold yourself to the same standard you’d expect from them. Test your tech, join on time, choose a professional background, and give the conversation your full attention. Candidates are evaluating you, too, and top talent has options.
- Do close the loop quickly. Tell candidates what happens next and when, then follow through. Speed and clarity are a competitive advantage in any market.
THE DON’TS
- Don’t treat it as a vibe check. Rapport matters, but “I liked them” isn’t a hiring criterion. Tie your impressions back to what the role requires.
- Don’t over-weight the polish of the setup. A frozen screen, a barking dog, or a less-than-perfect background says very little about how someone will perform in the job. Judge the substance, not the bandwidth.
- Don’t do all the talking. It’s tempting to spend the first ten minutes pitching the role. Give a brief overview, then let the candidate carry the conversation. You learn nothing while you’re speaking.
- Don’t multitask. Candidates can tell when you’re reading email, and the best ones will notice. It also means you’ll miss the very details you’re there to catch.
- Don’t let it run long or cut it short. Respect the time you promised. A screen that drags signals disorganization, and one that ends abruptly can feel like a decision was made in the first five minutes.
- Don’t skip the debrief. If more than one person is involved, compare notes soon after the call, before opinions harden and details fade.
THE BOTTOM LINE
A preliminary video interview isn’t a formality. For the candidate, it’s often the deciding factor in whether they move forward. For you, it’s the filter that determines the quality of everything that comes after. A focused, consistent, respectful screen helps you find the right people faster and leaves every candidate with a good impression of your organization, whether or not they get the job.
Looking to strengthen your screening process, or want help running it? We’d love to hear from you. Reach out to Karen Brennan, who handles The Strategy Group’s searches, at kbrennan@thestrategygroupllc.org.

